BY KYM SOSOLIK
Director, Leadership and
Organization Development
SMU Cox School of
Business, Executive Education
The advancement of
women to senior ranks of corporations really hasn’t changed much in the last 20
years. Today women are faced with the same two challenges: making it to the
corner office and commanding equal pay. According to a study conducted by
Catalyst, a New York City-based nonprofit research group, in 2008 only three
percent of U.S. Fortune 500 companies had women CEOs. Also according to
Catalyst, at the current rate of change, it will take women 47 years to reach
parity with men as corporate officers of Fortune 500 companies. How can this be
when universities are graduating women equal to or higher than men in
scholastic achievement, and women make up the majority of employees in most
corporations? Some believe women are treated differently from men when it comes
to leadership selection, and they cite historical organizational behaviors as
evidence of this bias. Others–
especially those in power positions – believe their leadership choices are
based solely on performance, not gender.
Discussions with a number
of women in top positions suggest that they have all faced one or more of these
barriers. For example, a senior vice president of a service organization stated
“Women do not network like our male counterparts. We do not have a golf game. I
find myself looking for networking opportunities that will provide real value
and there are just not that many available to women.”
To be competitive today,
businesses must employ workers who are innovative and capable of dealing with
complexity at an ever-increasing pace. The good news is that half the workers
today are working for female managers. But there is a huge gap between first
line managers and the c-suite for women. This gap exists despite data from a
recent McKinsey study that shows companies with more women directors show
greater returns on equity and higher ratings for organizational excellence in
areas such as leadership, accountability, innovation, work environment and
external orientation.
Challenges and Solutions
Interviews with top women
executives reveal many similarities among them that are not much different from
top men executives. Confidence, a sense of possibility, high self-expectations,
teamwork, and adaptability are the traits that rank highest on the list. One significant trait for all
women at the top is an enormous drive for success. They are continually
reassessing their own skills and seeking what they need to do to learn more.
Men who are leading Fortune 500 companies have said they do the same. This
group of extraordinary leaders exhibits the same skills, behaviors and
attitudes regardless of gender; they all got there based on performance. So why
are there so few women at the top?
Research suggests
that the biggest point of divergence between men’s and women’s perceptions
about leadership style is the belief that women are not strategic thinkers. The
general perception is that women
possess strong collaboration skills. If these perceptions influence candidate selection for
leadership positions based on performance, the result is that the percentage of women at the top is very small.
So how can these
perceptions be changed? Progress has been slow over previous decades, and there
is no indication these perceptions are changing any faster in this decade. There are laws in place to
protect women. Organizations are held accountable by stakeholders to do the
right thing. But mandates alone will not create real change. The first step in
creating real change will be the education of both men and women. Women leaders
are an untapped pool for talent, and organizations that increase the number of
women in leadership positions can enhance business success.
In addition, role
models or mentors play a very important function in the development of any
leader. Unfortunately for women there are very few female role models at the
top. Many women in top positions today were the first ones to get there. To effect real change, organizations must
develop formal mentoring programs for their high potential women leadership
candidates.
Organizations also have an
important role to play in creating equal opportunities for women and men. The
biggest change can occur as leaders set strategies for attracting talent, then
promote and reward appropriately. Recruiting women with the right skill sets
should be a top priority. Once the
talent is acquired, the real work begins with evaluating performance fairly and
rewarding accordingly. In order to encourage equal opportunities for women,
organizations should provide women identified as existing and upcoming leaders with
unique educational opportunities and publicly recognize women exhibiting effective
leadership behavior.
Performance is the
equalizer that will change the world as we know it for women in leadership. Both men and women have a stake in developing
and promoting women in corporate settings in order to produce the best business
results for the organization.
Change through Professional
Development
The real question becomes
how to provide leadership development to create a future very different from
today for the next generation of women leaders. Recent changes in the workplace
culture are making it necessary for women to take control over their career
choices. As more women enter the workforce, stay in the workforce longer, and
rise to top level positions, learning effective leadership becomes a basic
skill they need to survive.